Shelter Island, NY Vacation Rentals
Explore 186 vacation rentals, homes, and villas in Shelter Island, NY for your next getaway or business trip. Experience the privacy of a home with premium amenities such as Air Condition Homes, Homes with Pools and Best Affordable Homes, designed for a more comfortable and convenient stay. Every home is curated and professionally managed, with 24/7 local support, high-speed Wi-Fi, and premium linens included. With homes starting as low as $115 per night and featuring up to 8 bedrooms and 11 bathrooms, there's an option for every trip, from family vacations and group getaways to extended stays. However you're looking to experience your stay, Homes & Villas by Marriott has your next vacation home waiting. Marriott Bonvoy members can also earn and redeem points on every booking.
186 Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island
Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island by Amenities & Features
Get to Know Shelter Island
Shelter Island OverviewShelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and picturesque destination that offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. Accessible by ferry, this charming island is a blend of natural beauty, quaint charm, and rich history, making it an ideal spot for travelers seeking a peaceful retreat.
The island's natural landscapes are a major draw, with pristine beaches, tranquil marshes, and lush woodlands. Wades Beach and Crescent Beach provide visitors with soft sands and clear waters, perfect for sunbathing, swimming, and enjoying stunning sunsets. The Mashomack Preserve covers a third of the island and is a wildlife enthusiast's paradise, with over 2,000 acres of tidal creeks, oak woodlands, and fields that are home to a diverse array of birds and other wildlife.
Shelter Island is steeped in history, with several landmarks that tell the story of its past. The Shelter Island Historical Society offers insights into the island's heritage, housed in the 18th-century Havens House. The island's history is also evident in its architecture, with historic homes and churches dotting the landscape, including the Shelter Island Heights Historic District, where Victorian-era buildings have been beautifully preserved.
For those interested in outdoor activities, Shelter Island provides ample opportunities for kayaking, sailing, fishing, and hiking. The island's quiet country roads are perfect for cycling or leisurely drives, offering picturesque views and a chance to explore at a slower pace.
The culinary scene on Shelter Island is a delightful surprise, with a range of dining options that emphasize fresh, local ingredients. From casual eateries to upscale restaurants, visitors can enjoy a variety of dishes, including fresh seafood caught in the surrounding waters.
Accommodations on Shelter Island range from cozy bed and breakfasts to luxurious inns, providing options for every preference and budget. Many of these establishments offer personalized service and a chance to experience the island's hospitality firsthand.
Cultural experiences are also part of Shelter Island's charm, with art galleries, music concerts, and community events that showcase local talent and foster a sense of community.
In essence, Shelter Island is a destination that offers a blend of relaxation, natural beauty, and cultural richness. It's a place where time seems to slow down, inviting visitors to unwind, explore, and enjoy the simple pleasures of island life.
Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and picturesque destination that offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. Accessible by ferry, this charming island is a blend of natural beauty, quaint charm, and rich history, making it an ideal spot for travelers seeking a peaceful retreat. The island's natural landscapes are a major draw, with pristine beaches, tranquil marshes, and lush woodlands. Wades Beach and Crescent Beach provide visitors with soft sands and clear waters, perfect for sunbathing, swimming, and enjoying stunning sunsets. The Mashomack Preserve covers a third of the island and is a wildlife enthusiast's paradise, with over 2,000 acres of tidal creeks, oak woodlands, and fields that are home to a diverse array of birds and other wildlife. Shelter Island is steeped in history, with several landmarks that tell the story of its past. The Shelter Island Historical Society offers insights into the island's heritage, housed in the 18th-century Havens House. The island's history is also evident in its architecture, with historic homes and churches dotting the landscape, including the Shelter Island Heights Historic District, where Victorian-era buildings have been beautifully preserved. For those interested in outdoor activities, Shelter Island provides ample opportunities for kayaking, sailing, fishing, and hiking. The island's quiet country roads are perfect for cycling or leisurely drives, offering picturesque views and a chance to explore at a slower pace. The culinary scene on Shelter Island is a delightful surprise, with a range of dining options that emphasize fresh, local ingredients. From casual eateries to upscale restaurants, visitors can enjoy a variety of dishes, including fresh seafood caught in the surrounding waters. Accommodations on Shelter Island range from cozy bed and breakfasts to luxurious inns, providing options for every preference and budget. Many of these establishments offer personalized service and a chance to experience the island's hospitality firsthand. Cultural experiences are also part of Shelter Island's charm, with art galleries, music concerts, and community events that showcase local talent and foster a sense of community. In essence, Shelter Island is a destination that offers a blend of relaxation, natural beauty, and cultural richness. It's a place where time seems to slow down, inviting visitors to unwind, explore, and enjoy the simple pleasures of island life.
Weather in Shelter IslandShelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, experiences a climate that is generally mild and humid, with distinct seasons that each offer their own unique appeal to visitors.
Summer on Shelter Island, from June to August, is the most popular time for visitors, with warm temperatures averaging from the high 70s to mid-80s Fahrenheit. The humidity can be high, but the sea breezes often provide a refreshing respite. This is the perfect time for beach activities, boating, and enjoying the island's natural beauty. Precipitation is moderate, with occasional thunderstorms that can provide a dramatic display over the water.
Autumn, from September to November, brings cooler temperatures and less humidity. The highs range from the mid-60s to the low 70s in early autumn, dropping to the 50s as the season progresses. This is a wonderful time to experience the fall foliage, with the island's trees displaying vibrant colors. Rainfall is relatively consistent, but the crisp air and changing leaves make it a favorite time for many to visit.
Winter, from December to February, is the quietest season on Shelter Island, with cooler temperatures that average from the mid-30s to the low 40s. Snowfall can occur, but the island's coastal location often means less accumulation than on the mainland. While it's a more subdued time of year, the winter landscape offers a serene beauty, and the occasional dusting of snow can make for a picturesque setting.
Spring, from March to May, sees a gradual warming with temperatures ranging from the high 40s to the mid-60s. The island begins to bloom, and the humidity is generally low, making it a pleasant time for outdoor activities like hiking and bird watching. Rainfall is moderate, and the fresh spring air is invigorating after the winter months.
The climate is especially pleasant during the late spring to early summer and early autumn, when the temperatures are moderate, the humidity is lower, and the island's natural beauty can be enjoyed in more comfortable conditions. Whether you're looking to relax on the beach, explore the outdoors, or simply enjoy the peaceful atmosphere, Shelter Island offers a delightful escape in every season.
Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, experiences a climate that is generally mild and humid, with distinct seasons that each offer their own unique appeal to visitors. Summer on Shelter Island, from June to August, is the most popular time for visitors, with warm temperatures averaging from the high 70s to mid-80s Fahrenheit. The humidity can be high, but the sea breezes often provide a refreshing respite. This is the perfect time for beach activities, boating, and enjoying the island's natural beauty. Precipitation is moderate, with occasional thunderstorms that can provide a dramatic display over the water. Autumn, from September to November, brings cooler temperatures and less humidity. The highs range from the mid-60s to the low 70s in early autumn, dropping to the 50s as the season progresses. This is a wonderful time to experience the fall foliage, with the island's trees displaying vibrant colors. Rainfall is relatively consistent, but the crisp air and changing leaves make it a favorite time for many to visit. Winter, from December to February, is the quietest season on Shelter Island, with cooler temperatures that average from the mid-30s to the low 40s. Snowfall can occur, but the island's coastal location often means less accumulation than on the mainland. While it's a more subdued time of year, the winter landscape offers a serene beauty, and the occasional dusting of snow can make for a picturesque setting. Spring, from March to May, sees a gradual warming with temperatures ranging from the high 40s to the mid-60s. The island begins to bloom, and the humidity is generally low, making it a pleasant time for outdoor activities like hiking and bird watching. Rainfall is moderate, and the fresh spring air is invigorating after the winter months. The climate is especially pleasant during the late spring to early summer and early autumn, when the temperatures are moderate, the humidity is lower, and the island's natural beauty can be enjoyed in more comfortable conditions. Whether you're looking to relax on the beach, explore the outdoors, or simply enjoy the peaceful atmosphere, Shelter Island offers a delightful escape in every season.
Cultural Attractions in Shelter IslandShelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and culturally rich destination that offers a unique blend of arts, history, and local customs for the discerning traveler.
Begin your cultural exploration at the Shelter Island Historical Society, where the island's past comes to life. The Havens House Museum and its barn showcase local artifacts and exhibits that tell the story of Shelter Island's development from its Native American roots to its present-day community. The historical society also hosts various events and lectures that delve into the island's heritage.
Art enthusiasts will find solace in the intimate gallery spaces scattered across the island. Shelter Island is home to a vibrant community of artists, and their works are often displayed in local galleries and studios. The Shelter Island Artist Collective and various pop-up exhibitions provide a platform for both established and emerging artists, offering a glimpse into the island's creative pulse.
For those who revel in live music, Shelter Island's local bars and restaurants frequently feature performances by local musicians, especially during the summer months. The Perlman Music Program, founded by the renowned violinist Itzhak Perlman, is a highlight for classical music lovers. The program offers exceptional concerts by talented young musicians, and the bucolic setting of the campus adds to the enchantment of the performances.
The island's traditions are best experienced through its community events. The annual Shelter Island 10K Run is a festive occasion that brings together residents and visitors alike. The Shelter Island Oyster Festival is another local custom that celebrates the island's maritime heritage with fresh seafood and live entertainment.
Shelter Island's natural beauty complements its cultural offerings. The Mashomack Preserve covers a third of the island and is a haven for wildlife and nature lovers. Its trails and guided nature walks provide a peaceful retreat and an opportunity to learn about the local ecosystem.
Dining on Shelter Island is an experience in itself, with many restaurants offering locally sourced ingredients and seafood. Enjoying a meal at one of the island's charming eateries is a delightful way to engage with the local culture and savor the flavors of the region.
In Shelter Island, the pace is slower, the atmosphere is tranquil, and the cultural experiences are as rich as they are personal. It's a place where the arts, history, and local customs are woven into the fabric of everyday life, inviting visitors to step back in time and immerse themselves in the island's unique charm.
Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and culturally rich destination that offers a unique blend of arts, history, and local customs for the discerning traveler. Begin your cultural exploration at the Shelter Island Historical Society, where the island's past comes to life. The Havens House Museum and its barn showcase local artifacts and exhibits that tell the story of Shelter Island's development from its Native American roots to its present-day community. The historical society also hosts various events and lectures that delve into the island's heritage. Art enthusiasts will find solace in the intimate gallery spaces scattered across the island. Shelter Island is home to a vibrant community of artists, and their works are often displayed in local galleries and studios. The Shelter Island Artist Collective and various pop-up exhibitions provide a platform for both established and emerging artists, offering a glimpse into the island's creative pulse. For those who revel in live music, Shelter Island's local bars and restaurants frequently feature performances by local musicians, especially during the summer months. The Perlman Music Program, founded by the renowned violinist Itzhak Perlman, is a highlight for classical music lovers. The program offers exceptional concerts by talented young musicians, and the bucolic setting of the campus adds to the enchantment of the performances. The island's traditions are best experienced through its community events. The annual Shelter Island 10K Run is a festive occasion that brings together residents and visitors alike. The Shelter Island Oyster Festival is another local custom that celebrates the island's maritime heritage with fresh seafood and live entertainment. Shelter Island's natural beauty complements its cultural offerings. The Mashomack Preserve covers a third of the island and is a haven for wildlife and nature lovers. Its trails and guided nature walks provide a peaceful retreat and an opportunity to learn about the local ecosystem. Dining on Shelter Island is an experience in itself, with many restaurants offering locally sourced ingredients and seafood. Enjoying a meal at one of the island's charming eateries is a delightful way to engage with the local culture and savor the flavors of the region. In Shelter Island, the pace is slower, the atmosphere is tranquil, and the cultural experiences are as rich as they are personal. It's a place where the arts, history, and local customs are woven into the fabric of everyday life, inviting visitors to step back in time and immerse themselves in the island's unique charm.
Family friendly activities in Shelter IslandShelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and family-friendly destination that offers a variety of activities for children to enjoy. With its natural beauty, Shelter Island provides a peaceful retreat that is ideal for families looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.
One of the island's main attractions for families is the Mashomack Preserve, which covers over 2,000 acres of tidal creeks, oak woodlands, fields, and freshwater marshes. The preserve offers a range of kid-friendly trails that are perfect for a family hike. Children can engage with nature, spot local wildlife, and learn about the environment through the educational programs offered by the preserve.
Beaches are a big draw on Shelter Island, and Crescent Beach is a favorite for families. With its gentle waves and soft sand, it's an excellent spot for children to swim, build sandcastles, or collect shells. The calm waters of the Peconic Bay also make it a safe place for kayaking or paddleboarding, with rentals available nearby.
For a bit of history and education, the Shelter Island Historical Society provides a glimpse into the island's past. The Havens House Museum and its barn are filled with artifacts and exhibits that can captivate the curiosity of young minds. The historical society often hosts family-friendly events and workshops that are both fun and informative.
Families can also enjoy a round of miniature golf at Shelter Island's Whale's Tale, a charming course that offers a fun challenge for kids and adults alike. The course is adorned with nautical-themed obstacles, adding to the island's maritime charm.
When it's time to eat, Shelter Island has several family-friendly restaurants that offer a variety of cuisines, including fresh seafood, which is a staple of the island's dining scene. Many restaurants have outdoor seating areas where families can enjoy their meals in the fresh air.
Lastly, don't miss the opportunity to take a boat tour around Shelter Island. These tours provide a unique perspective of the island and its surroundings, and they often include opportunities to learn about local marine life, making it an educational experience for children.
Shelter Island's blend of natural beauty, outdoor activities, and educational experiences make it an ideal destination for families traveling with children. It's a place where kids can explore, learn, and have fun in a tranquil and picturesque setting.
Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and family-friendly destination that offers a variety of activities for children to enjoy. With its natural beauty, Shelter Island provides a peaceful retreat that is ideal for families looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life. One of the island's main attractions for families is the Mashomack Preserve, which covers over 2,000 acres of tidal creeks, oak woodlands, fields, and freshwater marshes. The preserve offers a range of kid-friendly trails that are perfect for a family hike. Children can engage with nature, spot local wildlife, and learn about the environment through the educational programs offered by the preserve. Beaches are a big draw on Shelter Island, and Crescent Beach is a favorite for families. With its gentle waves and soft sand, it's an excellent spot for children to swim, build sandcastles, or collect shells. The calm waters of the Peconic Bay also make it a safe place for kayaking or paddleboarding, with rentals available nearby. For a bit of history and education, the Shelter Island Historical Society provides a glimpse into the island's past. The Havens House Museum and its barn are filled with artifacts and exhibits that can captivate the curiosity of young minds. The historical society often hosts family-friendly events and workshops that are both fun and informative. Families can also enjoy a round of miniature golf at Shelter Island's Whale's Tale, a charming course that offers a fun challenge for kids and adults alike. The course is adorned with nautical-themed obstacles, adding to the island's maritime charm. When it's time to eat, Shelter Island has several family-friendly restaurants that offer a variety of cuisines, including fresh seafood, which is a staple of the island's dining scene. Many restaurants have outdoor seating areas where families can enjoy their meals in the fresh air. Lastly, don't miss the opportunity to take a boat tour around Shelter Island. These tours provide a unique perspective of the island and its surroundings, and they often include opportunities to learn about local marine life, making it an educational experience for children. Shelter Island's blend of natural beauty, outdoor activities, and educational experiences make it an ideal destination for families traveling with children. It's a place where kids can explore, learn, and have fun in a tranquil and picturesque setting.
Outdoor activities in Shelter IslandShelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and picturesque destination that offers a wealth of outdoor activities and natural wonders for those who love to immerse themselves in nature.
One of the island's most cherished natural attractions is the Mashomack Preserve, which covers over 2,000 acres, nearly one-third of the island. This nature preserve is a haven for wildlife and boasts a variety of habitats, including tidal creeks, oak woodlands, fields, and freshwater marshes. Nature enthusiasts can explore the preserve through a network of trails that offer opportunities for hiking and bird-watching. The diverse bird population includes ospreys, which are often seen nesting in the area.
Kayaking and paddleboarding are popular water activities that allow visitors to glide along the island's calm and clear waters, providing a peaceful way to explore the coastline and observe the local marine life. Shelter Island's numerous coves and inlets are perfect for these activities, especially around Coecles Harbor.
For those who prefer to travel on two wheels, Shelter Island's quiet country roads and gentle terrain make it an ideal location for cycling. Biking around the island not only offers a great workout but also allows visitors to take in the scenic beauty at a leisurely pace.
Beach lovers will find solace on the island's pristine shores. Crescent Beach, also known as Louis' Beach, is a favorite spot for swimming, sunbathing, and enjoying the stunning sunsets over the Peconic Bay. Wades Beach and Shell Beach are other popular destinations for a relaxing day by the sea, with their soft sands and clear waters.
Fishing enthusiasts can cast their lines in the rich waters surrounding Shelter Island. Whether you're fishing from the shore, a pier, or aboard a chartered boat, the area is known for its abundance of striped bass, bluefish, and fluke.
For a more structured outdoor experience, the Shelter Island Country Club offers a nine-hole public golf course known as "Goat Hill." This course provides not only a challenging game but also panoramic views of the island and beyond.
Shelter Island's natural beauty is complemented by its commitment to conservation and the environment, making it a truly special destination for outdoor lovers and those seeking a tranquil escape into nature. Whether you're hiking through lush preserves, paddling along serene waters, or simply enjoying the island's beaches, Shelter Island offers a peaceful retreat and an opportunity to reconnect with the great outdoors.
Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and picturesque destination that offers a wealth of outdoor activities and natural wonders for those who love to immerse themselves in nature. One of the island's most cherished natural attractions is the Mashomack Preserve, which covers over 2,000 acres, nearly one-third of the island. This nature preserve is a haven for wildlife and boasts a variety of habitats, including tidal creeks, oak woodlands, fields, and freshwater marshes. Nature enthusiasts can explore the preserve through a network of trails that offer opportunities for hiking and bird-watching. The diverse bird population includes ospreys, which are often seen nesting in the area. Kayaking and paddleboarding are popular water activities that allow visitors to glide along the island's calm and clear waters, providing a peaceful way to explore the coastline and observe the local marine life. Shelter Island's numerous coves and inlets are perfect for these activities, especially around Coecles Harbor. For those who prefer to travel on two wheels, Shelter Island's quiet country roads and gentle terrain make it an ideal location for cycling. Biking around the island not only offers a great workout but also allows visitors to take in the scenic beauty at a leisurely pace. Beach lovers will find solace on the island's pristine shores. Crescent Beach, also known as Louis' Beach, is a favorite spot for swimming, sunbathing, and enjoying the stunning sunsets over the Peconic Bay. Wades Beach and Shell Beach are other popular destinations for a relaxing day by the sea, with their soft sands and clear waters. Fishing enthusiasts can cast their lines in the rich waters surrounding Shelter Island. Whether you're fishing from the shore, a pier, or aboard a chartered boat, the area is known for its abundance of striped bass, bluefish, and fluke. For a more structured outdoor experience, the Shelter Island Country Club offers a nine-hole public golf course known as "Goat Hill." This course provides not only a challenging game but also panoramic views of the island and beyond. Shelter Island's natural beauty is complemented by its commitment to conservation and the environment, making it a truly special destination for outdoor lovers and those seeking a tranquil escape into nature. Whether you're hiking through lush preserves, paddling along serene waters, or simply enjoying the island's beaches, Shelter Island offers a peaceful retreat and an opportunity to reconnect with the great outdoors.
Transportation in Shelter IslandShelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and picturesque destination that offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. Reaching this charming island involves a combination of road and ferry travel, as there is no direct airport or train service to the island itself.
Most visitors arrive by car, driving to either Greenport on the North Fork or North Haven on the South Fork to catch the Shelter Island Ferry. The North Ferry connects Greenport to Shelter Island, while the South Ferry links North Haven to the island. These short ferry rides offer stunning views and are an integral part of the Shelter Island experience. There is no need to make a reservation for the ferry as it operates on a first-come, first-served basis, and the frequency of trips increases during the summer months to accommodate the higher volume of visitors.
Once on Shelter Island, the transportation options are more limited, which adds to the island's charm and laid-back atmosphere. While there is a taxi service available, many visitors choose to bring their own vehicles on the ferry to explore the island at their leisure. Bicycling is also a popular way to get around, with bike rentals available for those who didn't bring their own. The island's relatively small size and quiet roads make it ideal for leisurely bike rides.
For those who prefer to explore on foot, Shelter Island is quite walkable, especially in the Heights and the Center. These areas offer a variety of shops, restaurants, and attractions within easy walking distance. However, to fully appreciate the island's natural beauty, including its secluded beaches and nature preserves, having access to a car or bike is beneficial.
In terms of public transportation, options are limited. There is no formal bus service on the island, so planning is key if you're not bringing a vehicle. However, the island's compact size means that most destinations are within a reasonable driving or biking distance.
In conclusion, Shelter Island's transportation options are part of its charm, encouraging a slower pace and a more intimate connection with the island's natural beauty. Whether you're driving, biking, or walking, the island's laid-back rhythm and scenic landscapes are sure to make getting around a pleasure in itself.
Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, is a serene and picturesque destination that offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. Reaching this charming island involves a combination of road and ferry travel, as there is no direct airport or train service to the island itself. Most visitors arrive by car, driving to either Greenport on the North Fork or North Haven on the South Fork to catch the Shelter Island Ferry. The North Ferry connects Greenport to Shelter Island, while the South Ferry links North Haven to the island. These short ferry rides offer stunning views and are an integral part of the Shelter Island experience. There is no need to make a reservation for the ferry as it operates on a first-come, first-served basis, and the frequency of trips increases during the summer months to accommodate the higher volume of visitors. Once on Shelter Island, the transportation options are more limited, which adds to the island's charm and laid-back atmosphere. While there is a taxi service available, many visitors choose to bring their own vehicles on the ferry to explore the island at their leisure. Bicycling is also a popular way to get around, with bike rentals available for those who didn't bring their own. The island's relatively small size and quiet roads make it ideal for leisurely bike rides. For those who prefer to explore on foot, Shelter Island is quite walkable, especially in the Heights and the Center. These areas offer a variety of shops, restaurants, and attractions within easy walking distance. However, to fully appreciate the island's natural beauty, including its secluded beaches and nature preserves, having access to a car or bike is beneficial. In terms of public transportation, options are limited. There is no formal bus service on the island, so planning is key if you're not bringing a vehicle. However, the island's compact size means that most destinations are within a reasonable driving or biking distance. In conclusion, Shelter Island's transportation options are part of its charm, encouraging a slower pace and a more intimate connection with the island's natural beauty. Whether you're driving, biking, or walking, the island's laid-back rhythm and scenic landscapes are sure to make getting around a pleasure in itself.
Shelter Island FAQs
What is there to do on Shelter Island?Shelter Island offers a variety of activities for visitors. You can enjoy beautiful beaches like Crescent Beach, explore the Mashomack Preserve with its abundant wildlife and hiking trails, visit the Shelter Island Historical Society to learn about the island's past, or relax at one of the local spas. Boating, fishing, and kayaking are also popular activities. Don't forget to check out the local shops and restaurants in the charming town center.
Shelter Island offers a variety of activities for visitors. You can enjoy beautiful beaches like Crescent Beach, explore the Mashomack Preserve with its abundant wildlife and hiking trails, visit the Shelter Island Historical Society to learn about the island's past, or relax at one of the local spas. Boating, fishing, and kayaking are also popular activities. Don't forget to check out the local shops and restaurants in the charming town center.
How do you get to Shelter Island?Shelter Island is accessible by ferry. There are two ferry services: the North Ferry connects to Greenport on Long Island's North Fork, and the South Ferry connects to North Haven on the South Fork. You can bring a vehicle on the ferry or come as a foot passenger.
Shelter Island is accessible by ferry. There are two ferry services: the North Ferry connects to Greenport on Long Island's North Fork, and the South Ferry connects to North Haven on the South Fork. You can bring a vehicle on the ferry or come as a foot passenger.
Where is the best place to stay on Shelter Island?Shelter Island has a range of accommodations, from luxury hotels like The Pridwin Hotel and Sunset Beach to charming bed and breakfasts and inns such as the Shelter Island House or the Seven on Shelter. There are also vacation rentals available for those who prefer more privacy.
Shelter Island has a range of accommodations, from luxury hotels like The Pridwin Hotel and Sunset Beach to charming bed and breakfasts and inns such as the Shelter Island House or the Seven on Shelter. There are also vacation rentals available for those who prefer more privacy.
What dining options are available on Shelter Island?The island boasts a variety of dining options, from casual eateries to upscale restaurants. Popular spots include Vine Street Café, known for its fresh, local ingredients, and The Ram's Head Inn, which offers fine dining with a view. For a more laid-back atmosphere, try The Dory or Marie Eiffel Market.
The island boasts a variety of dining options, from casual eateries to upscale restaurants. Popular spots include Vine Street Café, known for its fresh, local ingredients, and The Ram's Head Inn, which offers fine dining with a view. For a more laid-back atmosphere, try The Dory or Marie Eiffel Market.
Are there any special events or festivals on Shelter Island?Shelter Island hosts several annual events, including the Shelter Island 10K race, the Shelter Island Music Festival, and the annual Art Show & Craft Fair. The summer season is particularly lively with outdoor concerts, farmers markets, and community gatherings.
Shelter Island hosts several annual events, including the Shelter Island 10K race, the Shelter Island Music Festival, and the annual Art Show & Craft Fair. The summer season is particularly lively with outdoor concerts, farmers markets, and community gatherings.
What should I pack for a trip to Shelter Island?Pack according to the season. Summers are warm, so bring light clothing, beachwear, and sunscreen. Spring and fall can be cooler, so layers are recommended. Comfortable walking shoes are a must for exploring the island. Don't forget to pack any necessary personal items, as shopping options on the island are limited.
Pack according to the season. Summers are warm, so bring light clothing, beachwear, and sunscreen. Spring and fall can be cooler, so layers are recommended. Comfortable walking shoes are a must for exploring the island. Don't forget to pack any necessary personal items, as shopping options on the island are limited.
More space, more privacy, more points with every home rental.
What makes Homes & Villas by Marriott Bonvoy a unique home rental experience? Unlike other home rental sites like AirBNB, when you book a vacation rental with Homes & Villas by Marriott Bonvoy you always have the whole place to yourself. Plus, as a member of Marriott Bonvoy, you can earn points towards free nights with every stay.

















