Sag Harbor, New York Vacation Rentals

Explore 101 rental homes and villas in Sag Harbor, New York for your next vacation or business travel. With private vacation home rentals, enjoy a more personalized stay and a wide range of amenities such as Homes with Pools, Air Condition Homes and Best Affordable Homes. With a wide range of homes to offer, pricing can start as low as $74 per night with homes containing as many as 9 bedrooms and 11 bathrooms. However you're looking to experience your stay, Homes and Villas by Marriott has your next vacation home waiting.

Types of vacation rentals in Sag Harbor

Where to stay in Sag Harbor

Show all homes

Booking a vacation rental in Sag Harbor, New York?

Here are some things to know to support your visit:

Sag Harbor Overview
Sag Harbor, a gem on the East End of Long Island, New York, is more than just a picturesque village—it's an enchanting blend of historic allure, cultural depth, and coastal splendor. Once a bustling whaling port, Sag Harbor has meticulously preserved its 19th-century charm, with its historic architecture and maritime legacy serving as the backdrop for a truly immersive experience. Stroll down the village's Main Street and you'll be transported to a bygone era, with its array of boutique shops, art galleries, and antique stores offering a treasure trove of unique finds. The Sag Harbor Whaling & Historical Museum, set in an 1845 Greek Revival mansion, stands as a testament to the village's whaling heritage and pivotal role in shaping the region. The cultural tapestry of Sag Harbor is rich and varied, with the Bay Street Theater at its heart, presenting an eclectic mix of performances that range from modern plays to beloved musicals. The Sag Harbor American Music Festival is an annual highlight, bringing together a diverse lineup of musicians to celebrate America's musical legacy in the village's intimate venues. For those drawn to the call of the ocean, Sag Harbor's beaches are a slice of paradise. The soft sands and gentle waves of the nearby Hamptons beckon beachgoers for days filled with swimming, sunbathing, and seaside relaxation. The Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge offers a tranquil escape for nature lovers, with trails meandering through habitats teeming with birds and wildlife. Sag Harbor has long been a muse for the literary set, with celebrated authors like John Steinbeck and E.L. Doctorow drawing inspiration from its serene environs. The village continues to honor this tradition with frequent literary events that nurture a vibrant community of readers and writers. The village's waterfront is alive with the spirit of the sea, with marinas that serve as gateways to boating adventures, fishing excursions, and breathtaking sailing charters that reveal the beauty of Peconic Bay. Culinary delights abound in Sag Harbor, where dining options range from cozy cafes to exquisite restaurants, many highlighting the freshest seafood and produce from local waters and farms. The surrounding vineyards and farm stands enhance the gastronomic journey with wine tastings and seasonal harvests. To truly savor the essence of Sag Harbor, consider the unparalleled experience of renting a private home. Imagine a secluded haven where you can bask in the comfort of your own space, many of which come with the added luxury of swimming pools, perfect for a refreshing dip after a day of exploration. Pet-friendly options ensure that your furry companions can join in the adventure, making for a complete family retreat. And with the village's stunning waterfront always within reach, your stay in Sag Harbor promises to be an idyllic escape that combines the tranquility of a private home with the charm of a historic seaside community.
Cultural Attractions in Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor, New York, nestled in the heart of the Hamptons, is a cultural gem that offers a unique blend of history, arts, and local customs. This picturesque village, with its deep-rooted maritime history and charming 18th and 19th-century architecture, is a haven for those who revel in cultural exploration. Begin your journey at the Sag Harbor Whaling & Historical Museum, housed in a preserved 19th-century mansion. Here, you can delve into the village's whaling past and gain insight into the lives of the sailors who once called Sag Harbor home. The museum's collection includes whaling tools, portraits, and scrimshaw, offering a tangible connection to the village's maritime heritage. Art enthusiasts will find solace in the local galleries that dot the village. The Grenning Gallery, for instance, showcases classical and contemporary realist art, often featuring works that reflect the natural beauty of the Hamptons. The Sara Nightingale Gallery offers a more modern and eclectic selection, with exhibitions that challenge and inspire. For those who appreciate live performances, Bay Street Theater is a cultural cornerstone of Sag Harbor. This intimate venue presents a year-round slate of plays, musicals, and comedy shows, often featuring renowned actors and directors. The theater's commitment to new works and premieres makes it a beacon for contemporary American theater. Music lovers can enjoy live jazz, folk, and classical performances at venues like the Sag Harbor American Music Festival. This annual event celebrates American music with free outdoor concerts and ticketed indoor performances, showcasing both local talent and nationally recognized artists. Sag Harbor's cultural scene is also reflected in its local customs and community events. The HarborFest, a waterfront festival held in September, celebrates the village's nautical history with whaleboat races, live music, and local food. It's an excellent opportunity to mingle with residents and experience the village's vibrant community spirit. Strolling through the historic streets of Sag Harbor, visitors can admire the well-preserved homes and buildings, many of which are listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The village's commitment to preservation allows you to step back in time and imagine the bustling port it once was. Dining in Sag Harbor is another cultural experience, with restaurants offering a range of cuisines that highlight local produce and seafood. Enjoy a meal at one of the village's eateries, where the ambiance often reflects the area's artistic and historic charm. In Sag Harbor, every visit is an opportunity to immerse yourself in a rich tapestry of culture, history, and local customs, all set against the backdrop of the scenic Hamptons. It's a destination that invites you to slow down, savor the arts, and connect with the past in a meaningful way.
Kids IconFamily friendly activities in Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor, New York, is a delightful destination for families traveling with children, offering a blend of cultural history, outdoor activities, and seaside charm that can keep the little ones engaged and entertained. Begin your family adventure at the Sag Harbor Whaling & Historical Museum, where kids can learn about the town's maritime past. The museum's exhibits are designed to be both educational and engaging, with artifacts and stories that bring the whaling era to life. Children can imagine themselves as sailors of yesteryear, exploring the high seas in search of adventure. For a breath of fresh air and a chance to stretch their legs, take the family to Mashashimuet Park. This green oasis in the heart of Sag Harbor provides ample space for children to run and play. With playground equipment, tennis courts, and ball fields, it's an ideal spot for a family picnic or a friendly game of catch. Bay Street Theater offers a variety of live performances throughout the year, including kid-friendly shows and educational programs. Check their schedule for family-oriented entertainment that can introduce children to the magic of theater. The Sag Harbor Marine Park is another great stop for families. Here, children can watch boats come and go, fish off the pier, or simply enjoy the scenic views of the harbor. The park's calm waters are also perfect for kayaking or paddleboarding, activities that can be enjoyed by older children under adult supervision. For a unique educational experience, visit the Children's Museum of the East End in nearby Bridgehampton. This interactive museum is designed specifically for children, with hands-on exhibits that encourage learning through play. Kids can explore a variety of themed areas, including a pretend grocery store and a construction zone. Don't forget to take a stroll down Sag Harbor's Main Street, where you'll find charming boutiques and ice cream shops that are sure to be a hit with the kids. Treat them to a scoop of their favorite flavor as you wander through this picturesque village. Sag Harbor's combination of historical intrigue, outdoor fun, and family-friendly attractions make it a wonderful destination for those traveling with children. Whether your family is looking to learn, play, or simply relax by the water, this quaint Long Island village has something to offer for every young traveler.
Nature IconOutdoor activities in Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor, New York, nestled in the heart of the Hamptons, is a picturesque village that offers a serene escape with a variety of natural wonders and outdoor activities for nature enthusiasts. The area's rich maritime history is complemented by its beautiful landscapes and opportunities for outdoor recreation. For those who love the water, Sag Harbor is a boater's paradise. The local marinas and the calm waters of the Peconic Bay provide the perfect setting for sailing, yachting, and fishing. Kayaking and paddleboarding are also popular activities, allowing visitors to explore the coastline at a leisurely pace, perhaps catching a glimpse of local wildlife such as ospreys and other seabirds. The Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, located a short drive from Sag Harbor, is an absolute must-visit for birdwatchers and wildlife photographers. The refuge's diverse habitats, including beaches, lagoons, and woodlands, are home to a variety of bird species, as well as small mammals and reptiles. The scenic trails offer a peaceful retreat into nature, with the chance to spot animals in their natural environment. Hiking enthusiasts will enjoy the Barcelona Neck Natural Resources Management Area, which features a network of trails through oak-hickory forests, tidal creeks, and salt marshes. The area is ideal for a quiet hike, where the rustling leaves and chirping birds provide a natural soundtrack to your adventure. For a unique outdoor experience, visit the Long Pond Greenbelt, a system of trails and freshwater ponds that stretches from Sag Harbor to the Atlantic Ocean. The area is a biodiversity hotspot, supporting rare plants and animals, and offers excellent opportunities for hiking, wildlife observation, and photography. Beach lovers will find Haven's Beach in Sag Harbor a delightful spot for sunbathing, swimming, and beachcombing. The beach's gentle waves and soft sands make it a family-friendly destination, perfect for a relaxing day by the sea. Lastly, the nearby vineyards of the North Fork offer a different kind of natural beauty. Take a scenic drive through the countryside, stopping at local wineries for tastings and tours. The vineyard vistas are particularly stunning during the fall harvest season, when the leaves turn into a tapestry of fiery colors. Sag Harbor's blend of maritime charm, natural beauty, and outdoor activities make it an ideal destination for those looking to connect with nature and enjoy the great outdoors. Whether you're paddling on the bay, hiking through forests, or simply enjoying the tranquility of a wildlife refuge, Sag Harbor offers a refreshing escape into nature's embrace.
Weather IconWeather in Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor, nestled in the Hamptons on the eastern end of Long Island, New York, offers a climate that is generally temperate and seasonally distinct, making it a delightful destination throughout the year. The summer months, from June to August, are the warmest and most popular time to visit Sag Harbor. Temperatures during this period average from the high 70s to mid-80s Fahrenheit (25-30°C), with occasional heat waves pushing temperatures higher. The Atlantic Ocean helps to moderate the heat, providing a refreshing sea breeze that is particularly enjoyable on the beaches. Humidity can be high, but it's often offset by the coastal winds. Precipitation is relatively evenly distributed throughout the year, but summer thunderstorms are not uncommon, adding to the overall rainfall. Autumn, from September to November, is a particularly pleasant time in Sag Harbor. The temperatures start to cool, ranging from the 60s to low 70s Fahrenheit (15-22°C) in September and dropping further as the season progresses. This is the time when the foliage begins to change, offering spectacular displays of color, especially in the nearby parks and countryside. The humidity drops, and the weather is generally comfortable for all sorts of outdoor activities, from sailing to wine tasting at local vineyards. Winter, from December to February, sees the coldest temperatures, with averages ranging from the mid-20s to the low 40s Fahrenheit (-4 to 4°C). Snowfall is variable, but Sag Harbor does experience occasional snowstorms that can transform the landscape into a winter wonderland. While it's the quietest season for tourism, the winter charm of the Hamptons can be quite enchanting, with fewer crowds and cozy fireside dining experiences. Spring, from March to May, brings a gradual warming with temperatures ranging from the 40s to the 60s Fahrenheit (4-15°C). The season starts off cool and can be somewhat unpredictable, with a mix of sunny days and spring showers. As the season progresses, the town and its natural surroundings come to life with blooming flowers and greenery. The most popular weather conditions are found in the summer, attracting visitors to the beaches and outdoor events. However, for those seeking a quieter experience with pleasant weather, the shoulder seasons of late spring and early autumn offer a perfect blend of mild temperatures and the natural beauty of Sag Harbor without the peak season crowds.
Transportation in Sag Harbor
Sag Harbor, New York, is a charming village located on the eastern end of Long Island, known for its rich maritime history and cultural scene. While it may not have the major airports or train stations of a large city, there are still several convenient ways to arrive and explore this picturesque destination. Most travelers heading to Sag Harbor begin their journey by flying into one of New York City's major airports—JFK or LaGuardia—and then either renting a car or taking a bus. The Hampton Jitney and the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) offer services from New York City to the towns near Sag Harbor, with the closest LIRR station being in Bridgehampton. From there, a short taxi or ride-sharing service can take you into the heart of the village. For those who prefer to drive, Sag Harbor is approximately a 2-hour drive from New York City, depending on traffic. This allows for a scenic journey through Long Island's picturesque landscapes. Once in Sag Harbor, you'll find that the village itself is quite walkable, with most shops, restaurants, and attractions such as the Whaling Museum, Bay Street Theater, and marinas within easy walking distance of each other. Biking is another popular way to get around, especially during the warmer months. The relatively flat terrain and scenic views make for an enjoyable ride. Bike rentals are available, allowing visitors to explore the surrounding areas, including nearby beaches and the beautiful Mashomack Preserve on Shelter Island, which is just a short ferry ride away. For those looking to explore the wider Hamptons area, having a car is beneficial. Public transportation options are limited outside of Sag Harbor, and many of the beautiful beaches, vineyards, and art galleries that the Hamptons are known for are spread out. In summary, while Sag Harbor may not have the extensive public transportation systems of a major city, it offers a variety of options for getting there and getting around. The village's compact size and charming streets make it a delight to explore on foot, while having a car will provide the freedom to discover the broader beauty of the Hamptons region.