Fire Island, New York Vacation Rentals

Explore 5 rental homes and villas in Fire Island, New York for your next vacation or business travel. With private vacation home rentals, enjoy a more personalized stay and a wide range of amenities such as Homes with Pools, Air Condition Homes and Pet-Friendly Homes. With a wide range of homes to offer, pricing can start as low as $182 per night with homes containing as many as 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. However you're looking to experience your stay, Homes and Villas by Marriott has your next vacation home waiting.

Types of vacation rentals in Fire Island

Where to stay in Fire Island

Show all homes

Booking a vacation rental in Fire Island, New York?

Here are some things to know to support your visit:

Fire Island Overview
Nestled off the southern coast of Long Island, Fire Island is a captivating barrier island that epitomizes the quintessential beach retreat. With its powdery white sands, crystal-clear Atlantic waters, and a car-free environment, this idyllic destination promises an unparalleled sense of tranquility and escape from the frenetic pace of everyday life. As you step off the ferry, you're transported into a world where the rhythm of the waves sets the pace. The island's beaches are not just beautiful; they are legendary. The waterfront is the heart of Fire Island, offering a pristine stretch of coastline that beckons sunbathers, swimmers, and water sports enthusiasts alike. The allure of the ocean is matched only by the charm of the communities that dot the shoreline. The crown jewel of Fire Island is undoubtedly the Fire Island Lighthouse. This historic beacon stands as a testament to the island's maritime heritage, and a climb to its summit rewards visitors with breathtaking views that stretch to the horizon. Nearby, the Fire Island National Seashore is a treasure trove of natural wonders. The Sunken Forest, with its enchanting boardwalk trail, invites you to immerse yourself in a rare ecological marvel, while the local fauna offers delightful encounters for wildlife aficionados. For a truly immersive experience, consider the luxury of renting a private home. Imagine waking up to the sound of the surf in a space that's exclusively yours, complete with all the comforts of home—and perhaps even a swimming pool to dip into on those warm summer days. Many of these homes are pet-friendly, so your furry companions can join in on the fun, making for a perfect family or group getaway. Ocean Beach serves as the vibrant heart of the island, where the spirit of community shines through. Here, you'll find a selection of dining options that range from laid-back beachside grills to sophisticated restaurants where the catch of the day is always on the menu. As the sun sets, the village comes alive with a nightlife that's as inviting as it is exciting. Each enclave on Fire Island has its own unique personality, from the family-oriented Kismet and Ocean Bay Park to the more secluded Water Island. The Pines and Cherry Grove are celebrated for their dynamic LGBTQ+ culture, offering an array of entertainment from jubilant parties to captivating drag shows. Fire Island is more than just a destination; it's an experience that melds the beauty of nature with the warmth of community life. Whether you're seeking a serene hideaway or a lively social scene, this island paradise offers a rare blend of privacy and camaraderie, all set against the backdrop of one of the East Coast's most magnificent beaches.
Cultural Attractions in Fire Island
Fire Island, New York, may be renowned for its pristine beaches and natural beauty, but it also offers a unique cultural experience for those interested in the arts, history, and local customs. This barrier island, accessible by ferry, is a world away from the hustle and bustle of city life, providing a serene backdrop for cultural exploration. While Fire Island doesn't have the traditional museums and galleries found in larger cities, it makes up for it with its own brand of cultural charm. The island's history is on display at the Fire Island Lighthouse, where visitors can learn about the maritime heritage of the area and enjoy panoramic views from the top. The lighthouse often hosts art exhibitions and historical displays that delve into the island's past and its significance to maritime navigation. Art enthusiasts will appreciate the local art scene that thrives during the summer months. Many of the island's residents are artists, and their work is often showcased in community spaces and during the Fire Island Summer Arts Festival. This event brings together a collection of visual arts, crafts, and performances, celebrating the creativity of the island's inhabitants and visiting artists. Live music is a staple of Fire Island's cultural offerings, with performances ranging from classical to contemporary. The outdoor decks of restaurants and bars come alive with the sound of music, providing an intimate setting for enjoying live performances against the backdrop of a stunning sunset. The island's culture is also reflected in its architecture, with the historic communities of Ocean Beach and Cherry Grove featuring charming cottages and boardwalks that tell the story of Fire Island's development as a vacation destination. Walking tours of these communities offer insights into the local customs and lifestyle that have evolved over the years. For those interested in theater, the Arts Project of Cherry Grove hosts a variety of performances, including cabarets, musicals, and plays, showcasing the talents of both local and visiting performers. This vibrant community is also known for its welcoming atmosphere and celebration of diversity, with events that highlight the island's inclusive spirit. Fire Island's natural environment also plays a role in its cultural life. The Sunken Forest, a rare maritime holly forest, offers guided tours that not only explore the unique ecology of the area but also touch on the human history that has shaped this delicate landscape. In summary, Fire Island offers a cultural experience that is as unique as its setting. It's a place where history, the arts, and local customs are woven into the fabric of daily life, offering visitors a chance to engage with culture in a relaxed and natural environment.
Kids IconFamily friendly activities in Fire Island
Fire Island, New York, is a delightful escape for families and a paradise for children, offering a blend of outdoor adventures, beach fun, and educational experiences. This car-free oasis is accessible by ferry, which adds an element of excitement for kids right from the start. Upon arrival, the pristine beaches are the main attraction. The soft sand is perfect for building sandcastles, while the gentle waves of the Atlantic Ocean provide a safe environment for paddling and swimming. Lifeguards are on duty at various beaches during the summer, ensuring a stress-free experience for parents. For a touch of nature and wildlife, the Sunken Forest is a must-visit. This rare maritime forest offers guided tours where families can learn about the local ecosystem. Children will be fascinated by the holly trees, red cedars, and the variety of birds that call this forest home. The boardwalk makes it easy for little ones to explore without getting tired. The Fire Island Lighthouse is another family-friendly destination. Kids can climb to the top for a panoramic view of the island and the ocean. The lighthouse also has a small museum where children can learn about the history of the area and the role of the lighthouse in maritime navigation. For a more relaxed day, families can enjoy a picnic at one of the many public areas equipped with tables and grills. The lack of cars means children can roam more freely, making it a safe playground for them to ride bikes, play frisbee, or fly kites. Throughout the summer, various communities on Fire Island host family-oriented events, such as outdoor movie nights, arts and crafts fairs, and small festivals. These events often include activities specifically designed for children, such as face painting, games, and live entertainment. Dining on Fire Island is also a treat for families. Many restaurants offer casual, kid-friendly atmospheres and menus that cater to younger palates. After dinner, families can indulge in a sweet treat from one of the island's ice cream shops. Fire Island's combination of natural beauty, relaxed atmosphere, and engaging activities make it an ideal destination for families traveling with children. It's a place where kids can enjoy the simple pleasures of beach life and parents can unwind, knowing that their little ones are having as much fun as they are.
Nature IconOutdoor activities in Fire Island
Fire Island, New York, is a slender barrier island off the southern coast of Long Island, renowned for its pristine beaches, serene atmosphere, and natural beauty. This car-free oasis is a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers, offering a variety of activities and sights that allow visitors to connect with the environment. The Sunken Forest is one of Fire Island's most enchanting natural wonders. This rare maritime forest is nestled behind the dunes and offers a boardwalk trail that meanders through holly, sassafras, and shadblow trees, with the canopy creating a cool, shady environment even on the sunniest days. The forest is also a haven for birdwatching, with many species of migratory birds stopping here throughout the year. For those who love the beach, Fire Island's miles of unspoiled shoreline provide the perfect setting for sunbathing, swimming, and beachcombing. The island's position creates ideal conditions for surfing, particularly at spots like Smith Point County Park. The park also offers camping facilities for those who wish to stay overnight and enjoy the starry skies. Kayaking and paddleboarding are popular activities in the calm waters of the Great South Bay, which lies between Fire Island and Long Island. Exploring the bay's inlets and marshes is a peaceful way to observe the local marine life, including herons, egrets, and even the occasional seal. For a panoramic view of the island and beyond, climb to the top of the historic Fire Island Lighthouse. The lighthouse is located at the western end of the National Seashore and offers guided tours that provide insight into the area's maritime history. The observation deck at the top affords breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean, the bay, and the surrounding landscapes. Hiking and biking are also popular on Fire Island, with the island's relatively flat terrain making it accessible for all levels of fitness. The Fire Island National Seashore offers several trails that allow visitors to explore the island's diverse ecosystems, from dunes to salt marshes. For a more secluded experience, the Otis Pike Fire Island High Dune Wilderness is the only federally designated wilderness area in New York State. This area offers a more rugged, untouched environment where visitors can hike and camp amidst the dunes and wildlife. Fire Island's combination of natural beauty, outdoor activities, and a tranquil atmosphere makes it an ideal destination for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life and immerse themselves in nature. Whether you're seeking adventure or relaxation, Fire Island's natural wonders and outdoor activities are sure to provide an unforgettable experience.
Weather IconWeather in Fire Island
Fire Island, New York, is a slender barrier island off the southern coast of Long Island, known for its pristine beaches, natural beauty, and vibrant communities. The weather on Fire Island is typical of the Northeastern United States, with four distinct seasons that offer a variety of experiences for visitors. Summer, from June to August, is the peak season for Fire Island, with warm and often humid conditions. Average high temperatures hover around the upper 70s to mid-80s Fahrenheit (25-30°C), making it perfect for beach activities, swimming, and sunbathing. The island's ocean breezes can provide a refreshing counter to the humidity, and occasional thunderstorms are common in the afternoons. Fall, from September to November, brings cooler temperatures and less humidity. The highs range from the mid-60s to low 70s Fahrenheit (18-22°C) in September, gradually cooling as the season progresses. This is a wonderful time to enjoy the island's natural beauty as the foliage changes color, and the summer crowds have dissipated. Winter, from December to February, is the quietest time on Fire Island, with most of the seasonal communities closing down. The temperatures can be quite cold, with highs typically in the 30s and 40s Fahrenheit (1-9°C), and lows often dropping below freezing. Snowfall can occur, but the proximity to the ocean often means less accumulation than on the mainland. Spring, from March to May, sees a gradual warming with temperatures ranging from the upper 40s to the mid-60s Fahrenheit (9-18°C). The weather can be unpredictable, with a mix of sunny days and spring showers. This is a great time to visit for those looking to enjoy the tranquility of the island without the summer crowds. The most popular weather conditions are prevalent in the summer months when the warm temperatures and sunny skies make for ideal beach conditions. However, for those seeking a quieter visit with pleasant weather, late spring and early fall offer comfortable temperatures and fewer visitors. The shoulder seasons also provide unique opportunities to witness the island's wildlife and natural landscapes without the peak season bustle.
Transportation in Fire Island
Fire Island, New York, is a slender barrier island off the southern coast of Long Island, known for its pristine beaches, serene atmosphere, and vibrant LGBTQ+ community. This car-free oasis is accessible primarily by ferry, which adds to its charm and seclusion. Travelers typically arrive at one of the various towns on Long Island and then take a ferry from Bay Shore, Sayville, or Patchogue to reach Fire Island. The ferry schedules vary by season and destination within Fire Island, so it's advisable to check the latest timetables before planning your trip. During the summer months, ferries run more frequently to accommodate the influx of visitors. Once on Fire Island, the primary mode of transportation is by foot or bicycle. The island is known for its walkability, with boardwalks and sandy paths connecting homes, hotels, and the beach. The absence of cars makes for a peaceful and environmentally friendly atmosphere, allowing visitors to enjoy the natural beauty without the noise and pollution of traffic. For those who need to transport luggage or groceries, wagons are a common sight and can be rented or borrowed in many of the communities. Additionally, water taxis are available for traveling between the different communities on the island, offering a quick and scenic way to get around. It's important to note that while Fire Island is walkable, distances between communities can be significant, so be prepared for a fair amount of walking if you plan to explore beyond your immediate area. Bicycles are a popular alternative for longer distances and can be rented from several shops on the island. In summary, Fire Island's transportation options are part of what makes it a unique and tranquil retreat. The ferry ride sets the tone for a getaway that is both disconnected from the hustle and bustle of city life and intimately connected with nature. Once there, the walkable communities and the easygoing pace of bicycle and water taxi travel allow visitors to fully immerse themselves in the laid-back island lifestyle.