Mitchell, Indiana Vacation Rentals

Explore 9 rental homes and villas in Mitchell, Indiana for your next vacation or business travel. With private vacation home rentals, enjoy a more personalized stay and a wide range of amenities such as Air Condition Homes, Pet-Friendly Homes and Best Affordable Homes. With a wide range of homes to offer, pricing can start as low as $111 per night with homes containing as many as 8 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms. However you're looking to experience your stay, Homes and Villas by Marriott has your next vacation home waiting.

Types of vacation rentals in Mitchell

Where to stay in Mitchell

Show all homes

Booking a vacation rental in Mitchell, Indiana?

Here are some things to know to support your visit:

Mitchell Overview
Mitchell, Indiana, is a hidden gem tucked away in the heartland of America, offering a serene escape with a rich tapestry of historical and natural attractions. This quaint town is a treasure trove for those seeking to immerse themselves in the tranquility of a bygone era, complemented by the comforts of modern living. At the heart of Mitchell's allure is the Virgil I. "Gus" Grissom Memorial, a poignant homage to the hometown hero and pioneering astronaut. Visitors are captivated by the collection of space artifacts and Grissom's personal effects, providing an inspiring journey through America's spacefaring history. Nature enthusiasts will find their paradise at Spring Mill State Park, a verdant oasis where the past and present converge. The park's Pioneer Village, complete with a fully operational gristmill and historic buildings, transports guests to the 1800s, while the Donaldson Cave system invites the adventurous to discover subterranean wonders. Enhance your stay by renting a private home, where you can savor the luxury of your own space, often complete with a swimming pool to cool off during those warm Indiana summers. Many of these homes are pet-friendly, ensuring that your furry companions can join in on the fun. Mitchell's waterfront is not to be overlooked, offering a picturesque setting for leisurely strolls and tranquil moments by the water. It's the perfect backdrop for a family picnic or a quiet afternoon with a good book. The Persimmon Festival is a highlight of the year, a vibrant celebration of local culture and the beloved persimmon fruit. This week-long event is filled with parades, pageants, and the much-anticipated persimmon pudding contests, offering a slice of Americana and a chance to bond with the warm-hearted locals. For a touch of elegance, the Mitchell Opera House stands as a testament to the town's cultural heritage. This beautifully restored venue provides an intimate setting for an array of performances, from toe-tapping live music to captivating theater productions. Dining in Mitchell is a cozy affair, with local eateries serving up hearty, home-style meals that epitomize Midwestern hospitality. Each restaurant is a doorway to friendly conversation and a welcoming atmosphere that will make you feel right at home. Mitchell, Indiana, is more than just a destination; it's an experience wrapped in the comfort of a private retreat, the excitement of historical discovery, and the joy of simple pleasures. It's a place where every traveler can find their own slice of peace and nostalgia, all within the embrace of a community that values its roots and the natural beauty that surrounds it.
Cultural Attractions in Mitchell
Mitchell, Indiana, may not be the first place that comes to mind when you think of a cultural hub, but this small town has its own unique charm and a few surprises for the arts and history enthusiast. Begin your cultural exploration at the Carnegie Hall of Mitchell, which is one of the few remaining Carnegie-funded buildings and serves as a center for local arts and performances. The hall hosts a variety of events throughout the year, including live music performances that cater to a range of tastes, from classical to contemporary genres. For a deep dive into history, the Mitchell Opera House, another historic venue, offers a glimpse into the town's past while also providing a stage for live performances and community events. The opera house has been restored to its former glory and is a testament to the town's commitment to preserving its cultural heritage. Art enthusiasts will appreciate the local art scene that can be found at various community events and festivals. The Persimmon Festival, an annual celebration of the native persimmon fruit, features not only local customs and food but also showcases arts and crafts from the region. Here, visitors can experience the town's traditions and enjoy the work of local artisans. Mitchell is also the gateway to the fascinating history of Southern Indiana's limestone industry. The nearby town of Bedford, known as the "Limestone Capital of the World," has the Indiana Limestone Heritage Trail, which provides insights into the stone that built the nation's most iconic buildings. While Mitchell may not have the extensive array of museums and galleries found in larger cities, its historical sites and community-driven cultural events offer a warm, intimate experience of Midwestern artistry and heritage. The town's slower pace allows visitors to savor each cultural encounter, from live music in historic settings to local festivals that celebrate the town's unique identity. For those willing to venture a bit further, the surrounding areas of Lawrence County offer additional historical sites, outdoor sculptures, and the scenic beauty of Spring Mill State Park, where visitors can explore a pioneer village and learn about the region's history. In Mitchell, Indiana, the cultural traveler will find a quiet but meaningful celebration of the arts, history, and local customs, all set against the backdrop of America's heartland.
Kids IconFamily friendly activities in Mitchell
Mitchell, Indiana, may be a small town, but it offers a delightful array of activities that are perfect for families traveling with children. This quaint community is home to attractions that will not only entertain but also educate young minds. One of the main attractions in Mitchell is Spring Mill State Park. This beautiful park is a natural playground for kids, with its rolling hills, deep forests, and flowing creeks. The park's Pioneer Village is a living history exhibit where children can step back in time and see how Hoosiers lived in the early 1800s. With costumed interpreters and working craftsmen, it's an interactive experience that brings history to life. The park also boasts the Gus Grissom Memorial Museum, dedicated to the local astronaut and second American to fly in space. The museum features space-related exhibits that are sure to captivate any child interested in astronauts and outer space. It's an inspiring visit that highlights the achievements of a hometown hero. For those looking for a bit of subterranean adventure, Bluespring Caverns Park offers a fascinating look into the world below. The park's guided boat tours take families through an underground river system, where they can learn about geology and the unique animals that inhabit the darkness, such as blindfish and crayfish. It's an educational and thrilling experience that children will remember for years to come. If your kids love sweets, a stop at the local candy store, Grandma's Pantry, is a must. They offer a variety of old-fashioned candies and treats that will delight any child's sweet tooth. For a relaxing end to the day, visit the Mitchell City Park. It's a great spot for a family picnic, and the playground equipment provides a perfect outlet for kids to burn off some energy. Mitchell, Indiana, may not have the big-name attractions of a large city, but its charm and family-oriented activities make it a hidden gem for those traveling with children. From exploring natural wonders to learning about space travel, Mitchell offers a unique and memorable experience for the whole family.
Nature IconOutdoor activities in Mitchell
Mitchell, Indiana, is a treasure trove for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers, offering a serene escape into the heart of the Midwest's natural beauty. The area is most famous for Spring Mill State Park, a stunning representation of Indiana's diverse landscapes and rich history. Spring Mill State Park is the crown jewel of Mitchell's outdoor attractions. This expansive park features a variety of natural wonders, including lush forests, rolling hills, and deep caves. The park's cave systems, such as Twin Caves and Bronson Cave, are a highlight for adventurous visitors, offering guided boat tours that reveal a subterranean world of stalactites, stalagmites, and unique cave-dwelling wildlife. Hiking enthusiasts will find a network of trails winding through the park, ranging from easy walks to more challenging treks. The trails meander through dense woodlands, along creek beds, and past the park's restored 19th-century gristmill, which is part of a pioneer village that offers a glimpse into Indiana's past. For those who enjoy water-based activities, Spring Mill State Park includes the 23-acre Spring Mill Lake. Here, visitors can rent paddleboats to explore the tranquil waters or try their hand at fishing for bluegill and largemouth bass. The lake's surrounding picnic areas make for a perfect family outing or a peaceful spot to relax and enjoy the scenery. Bird watchers and wildlife enthusiasts will appreciate the park's diverse ecosystems, which are home to a variety of species. Keep an eye out for white-tailed deer, wild turkeys, and numerous bird species that inhabit the park's forests and fields. In addition to the natural attractions, Mitchell is located near the Hoosier National Forest, which offers even more opportunities for outdoor recreation. With over 200,000 acres of protected land, the forest is ideal for hiking, horseback riding, mountain biking, and camping. The forest's rolling hills, scenic vistas, and quiet hollows provide a perfect backdrop for those seeking solitude and a deep connection with nature. Mitchell, Indiana, may be a small town, but its access to some of the state's most beautiful natural wonders and outdoor activities makes it a big draw for nature lovers. Whether you're exploring the depths of a cave, hiking through dense forests, or simply enjoying the tranquility of a lakeside picnic, Mitchell offers an outdoor experience that is both enriching and unforgettable.
Weather IconWeather in Mitchell
Mitchell, Indiana, nestled in the heart of the Midwest, experiences a four-season climate that offers a variety of weather conditions throughout the year, each with its own distinct charm. The summer months, from June to August, are warm and often humid, with average high temperatures ranging from the low to mid-80s Fahrenheit. These months can also bring occasional thunderstorms, contributing to the overall precipitation. Despite the humidity, summer is a popular time for visitors looking to enjoy outdoor activities such as hiking in the nearby Hoosier National Forest or exploring Spring Mill State Park. Autumn, from September to November, is a delightful season in Mitchell. The air becomes crisper, and the humidity drops, making it a comfortable time for outdoor exploration. The fall foliage is a spectacular sight, with the leaves turning vibrant shades of red, orange, and yellow. Average temperatures during this season range from the high 70s in early September to the low 50s by late November. Winter, from December to February, can be quite cold, with average temperatures ranging from the low 20s to the mid-30s. Snowfall is common, though not usually excessive, providing a picturesque setting for the holiday season. This is a quieter time for tourism, but those who enjoy the serene beauty of a Midwestern winter will find Mitchell enchanting. Spring, from March to May, is a season of renewal and can be quite variable. Temperatures gradually warm, ranging from the high 40s in March to the high 60s by May. This season can also be wet, with April typically being the rainiest month, but the rainfall brings lush greenery and blooming wildflowers, making it a beautiful time to visit the area's natural attractions. The most pleasant weather conditions are often found in late spring and early fall when temperatures are moderate, and humidity is lower. These times of the year provide the ideal climate for enjoying Mitchell's outdoor activities and scenic beauty without the extremes of summer heat or winter chill. Whether you're looking to explore the great outdoors or soak in the small-town charm, Mitchell offers a welcoming atmosphere in any season.
Transportation in Mitchell
Mitchell, Indiana, may not be as bustling as some major cities, but it offers a quaint charm and several transportation options for visitors. This small town in Lawrence County is best reached by road, as it does not have its own commercial airport or train station. Visitors often arrive by car, either their own or a rental, via State Highway 37, which is the main route connecting Mitchell to larger cities such as Bloomington to the north and Bedford to the east. For those flying in, the nearest airport is Monroe County Airport in Bloomington, about 30 miles north of Mitchell. From there, renting a car is the most convenient way to reach Mitchell and explore the surrounding area. Alternatively, Indianapolis International Airport is a larger hub about 90 miles north of Mitchell, offering a wider range of flight options and rental car services. Once in Mitchell, getting around is relatively straightforward. The town is small enough that it can be quite walkable, especially in the downtown area where shops, restaurants, and some local attractions are located. However, to fully enjoy the surrounding attractions, such as Spring Mill State Park and the Virgil I. Grissom Memorial, having a car is beneficial. These sites are a short drive from the town center and are not serviced by public transportation. Mitchell does not have a public transportation system, so visitors will need to rely on their own vehicles or taxis for longer distances. Ride-sharing services may be limited due to the town's size, so it's advisable to check availability in advance or plan for alternative transportation. For those interested in local history, the Gus Grissom Boyhood Home and the Mitchell Opera House are within walking distance of each other in the heart of Mitchell. The town also hosts events like the Persimmon Festival, which draws visitors from across the region. In summary, while Mitchell, Indiana, is not a destination with extensive public transportation options, its small-town charm and proximity to natural and historical sites make it a pleasant place to visit. A car is recommended for those looking to explore beyond the town center, but within Mitchell itself, visitors can enjoy a leisurely pace and the ease of walking to nearby attractions.